|
|
|
Jim's
rating on
this stock |
STOCK
SYMBOL |
Closing
price that
day |
Full Company Name |
|
 |
CAT |
42.25 |
|
|
|
Jim:
CAT is about as
cyclical as it gets.
It obviously the
worst kind of
company, right?...
going into a
recession... an
earth mover?... So
the conventional
wisdom would tell
you to use any
strength to sell
CAT...
But this is a case
where conventional
wisdom is wrong, and
the company is very
much right...
You see, the company
has a bit of a
quandary...
Management is very
bullish, but the
analysts all think
we're going into the
Great Depression,
and CAT's business
will be crushed...
So who do we
believe?...
On the conference
call, management
predicted another
good year in 2009,
with the second half
of the year pulling
CAT up... CAT
doesn't expect any
serious earnings
interruption. They
expect earnings to
be flat
year-over-year...
amazing, given the
deterioration of the
global economy. They
think many of their
markets remain
strong. And they
don't have any
problems getting
financing, as much
as people thought
they did... So,
they're house of
pleasure...
At the same time,
analysts are
slashing estimates,
predicting financial
Armageddon... kind
of the end of
days...
Fortunately, in
Cramerica, we don't
have to believe
either side...
We just have to look
at that juicy
dividend, and it
tells us everything.
You see, once again,
because of the
dramatic decline in
a stock... CAT is
another "accidental
high yielder"...
just like NUE was
two weeks ago...
Right now, based on
next year's annual
dividend payout of
4.172, the stock
yields about 4%.
That makes it a buy.
Now, if it goes
lower, and it yields
about 4.5%, we'll
buy more... And, at
4.75%, we'll buy
more... and at 5%,
we will jump up and
down and be
thrilled.
See, the company's
paying us to wait to
see who's right,
management or the
bearish analysts
and, frankly, I'm
willing to take
their money and see
how things play
out...
CAT was never meant
to be a
high-yielder...
CAT's yield was puny
when the stock was
at $80, because this
is a cautious
company that always
kept its dividend
low, because it
didn't want to be
stuck paying out too
much if times got
tough.
Well now times are
tough...
|
|
Continued below...
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Just endorsed by
Oprah...
...as her
all-time favorite must-have gadget:
See what all the talk is
about!...
THE AMAZING NEW KINDLE
READER...
click image or learn more
here |
|
 |
|
 |
|
The New Kindle eBook Reader |
|
|
|
|
Tuesday,
November 4, 2008
(Cont'd from
above)...
CAT's stock has
been cut in
half, and now
the company's
paying out just
the right
amount... to
make it so you
can buy this one
and wait out the
recession.
Now, in past
recessions, CAT
would have,
unbelievably,
lost money. But
I look at the
bear case this
time around,
that CAT's
earnings will
get cut in half,
to $2.50 a
share, and the
bear case
convinces me
that this is an
incredible
buy!...
That's right!...
The bear case
convinces me
it's a buy,
because it will
still be able to
more than pay
out that
dividend.
We all know the
fundamentals
here are totally
devoid of
pulcritude, but
that doesn't
mean the stock
won't work. The
ISM numbers,
whatever they
are, are getting
worse... the
dollar's getting
stronger...
although it's
still weaker
than it was a
year ago, making
CAT's equipment
relatively more
expensive versus
its foreign
competitors.
Energy looks
really bad...
Housing is just
unbelievably
awful...
although
management
pointed out that
it saw some
signs of
stabilizing. Of
course, they're
the only ones
that saw signs
of
stabilization.
Then again,
there are
reasons to
believe that
CAT's management
may actually
know what it's
talking about...
Unsold new-home
inventories have
been dropping.
You know I think
that we will see
a recovery next
year in
housing...
Higher steel
prices, which
had been hurting
CAT should
become less of a
problem as steel
gets cheaper.
CAT's putting
through price
increases and it
thinks those, in
combination with
its new
products, will
keep its
earnings healthy
next year.
Here's what you
have to
understand...
The analysts are
behind the
curve... They're
saying things
are going to be
terrible next
year, but CAT's
stock already
reflects that.
It's been to $33
and back. And,
at that price,
it was
reflecting not
just a
recession, but a
full
depression!...
And that's not
going to happen.
If CAT's stock
goes back to
$33, where it
will yield 5.2%,
I would
literally back
up the truck and
buy even more of
it!...
CAT's yield is
so high because
the stock has
already come
down. The
analysts are
just telling us
what the share
price already
shows. Don't
forget, we are
betting on a
massive
infrastructure
giveaway under a
President Obama,
or even
McCain... He
looks like he'll
be the winner
tonight, but
what do we
know?...
And when you
build roads, you
know what you
need... this is
what you do, you
buy a million of
these and,
believe me,
Obama's not
going to be
buying Kubotas
(another
equipment brand)
for this work!
Caterpillar,
which remember,
is based in
Illinois
(Obama's home
state) is a
fabulous Obama
play... This one
"pays" in
Peoria...
As long as CAT
is yielding more
than 4% or
around there, I
think it's a
buy. The worst
thing that
happens is it
goes lower, and
you get to buy
more with a
higher yield,
something I'm
cheering for.
If it goes up,
we're going to
scale out just
like the other
stocks that go
up so much...
Once it gets to
a 3% yield,
we're going to
sell some.
If CAT's
management turns
out to be wrong,
and the analysts
turn out to be
right, the stock
is already
priced like
that's the case
and it's paying
out that fat
dividend...
Hey, what if
CAT's management
is right and the
analysts are
wrong?...
I'm usually
willing to pay
12x earnings for
a cyclical
stock... So, if
CAT does the $5
bucks that they
think it can,
I'm talking
about $60 (a
share stock
price)... Hey,
43% higher than
the current
price!
If its earnings
get cut in half,
it trades to
$30.
$20 up, or $10
down, with a 4%
yield?... It
would be
reckless not to
pull the
trigger...
Here's the
bottom line...
The Bottom Line!:
Caterpillar Inc. (CAT)'s
another
artificially-high
yielder, a total
tractor error in
your favor,
where the
bearish analysts
are still trying
to catch up to
the share price,
which has
already been cut
in half... CAT's
dividend is
safe. So long as
it's yielding
over 4%, or
anywhere within
the vicinity, I
would be a size
buyer.
[verbatim recap]
Read Jim's next Segment
here
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
 |
 |
|
|
|
Search for Jim's past comments about a specific
stock. Use
ticker symbol or company name in quotes
(e.g., GOOG or "Google") |
|
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|